ShareLife Blog

Increasing organ and tissue donor registration numbers does not increase actual donor rates.

Sunday, November 03, 2013

ShareLife Australia

Today, The Sunday Telegraph has launched a campaign in collaboration with Pride of Australia medal winner, Will Chapman, to address low rates of organ donation in Australia and to shed some light on the facts. It is important to hear the stories of those who are waiting and in need of a transplant. The sad truth is that many die waiting.

Often the public is led to believe that the answer to increasing the number of organ donors is as simple as increasing registration numbers. This is not the case. There is, however, a direct correlation between expertly trained staff working as donor coordinators in hospitals and the positive impact this has on organ donor identification and consent rates.

Over 90% of Australians support organ donation and more than five million are registered donors. We have dedicated experts working across the country and excellent transplant outcomes in Australia.

Australia's organ donor numbers have improved over the last year and this is good news. Twice as many transplants occur per capita in many other countries. Australia is currently ranked 21st in the world based on number of deceased organ donors per capita. There are no significant or relevant disparities between the number of people who could be potential donors in Australia and the numbers in countries that have much higher rates.

In 2012 there were 15.6 donors per million people in Australia. In the USA there were 26 dpmp and in Spain, the world leader, there were 35.6 dpmp.

The key is to improve identification and consent rates. This is successfully achieved when a nationally coordinated system is in operation and hospitals are given the resources and the world's best practice system to model changes on.

The community will is there. The federal government funding is there. Since 2009 $40 million has been allocated each year. In 2008 there were 846 recipients who received organs from deceased donors. Last year there were 354 deceased donors and 1052 transplant recipients in Australia.

We must ensure that this opportunity to save many more lives is realised. The Spanish lead the way, many countries are following. We must remain focused on what is possible and continue to strive for world-leading organ donation and transplant numbers. 

It's also important to take this opportunity to recognise and thank Australia's donors and donor families and also to thank those who may have wanted to donate but have not had the opportunity.

The power of the’ick’ factor in organ donation.

Thursday, October 03, 2013

By Assistant Professor Holly Northam

Holly is a director of ShareLife Australia and a leading figure in the organ and tissue donation sector in Australia. Her full bio is here. This article first appeared in Nursing Review.

Over the last few weeks a number of incidents in the public sphere have highlighted the problem of callous, inaccurate and insensitive representation of organ donation. The BBC faced strong complaint and approbation from the NHS for its depiction of organ donation in a recent television drama. In Australia last week a television program aired which presented a case of a death and subsequent organ donation. This program created outrage amongst nursing colleagues and those who are awaiting organ transplantation for its poor portrayal of organ donation and nurses. A strongly voiced view from my colleagues was that the outcomes could negatively colour the organ donation views of those who viewed the episode. This event coincided with a discussion about the release of a new book by a liver transplant surgeon aimed for public consumption, displayed in the new books section of a public library and picked up by a family member of an organ donor. This book was passed for review to Donor Families Australia. The donor family members were deeply distressed by insensitivity displayed in the portrayal of the organ donation surgical process and the apparent relegation of the donor to a vessel for organs.

A real anxiety about organ donation held by many in our community is sometimes referred to as the ‘ick’ factor and includes the idea of bodily mutilation, disrespect for the grieving family and confusion about the terminology and determination of death. The organ donation sector describes these fears as the ‘myths’ of organ donation. These fears and uncertainties are known to intrude and sometimes strongly influence the decision making process of people contemplating their own or their relatives’ death and organ and tissue donation decision. Despite an increase in the number of organ donors in Australia since the introduction of funding to facilitate the clinical requirements of organ donation, 2013 figures indicate around 45% of families still decline the request for donation, a figure that remains effectively unchanged across the last decade. For this reason Australia still lags well behind most developed countries in organ donation rates with a rate half that of Spain who has the highest donation rate, and seeks family consent for every donation despite its Opt out scheme. It is possible that despite the altruistic character of Australians and a willingness to support the idea of organ donation; many of us carry a subconscious hesitation to agree to organ or tissue donation underpinned by distrust in the process.

I am saddened that despite the general acknowledgement in the public conversation in Australia that we should increase our organ donation rates with calls for opt-out legislative frameworks to over-ride the influence of families in the decision making process ; many thought leaders remain amazingly insensitive to the impact they have in influencing the organ donation decisions of the community. People who include not only those who may be required to make a decision in the future about organ donation; but also grieving donor families who, having made a decision to donate, benefit from affirmation for what is often a harrowing experience.

The experience of empathy and compassion contribute to the trust and hope which is essential for families to make a decision to donate, and for our community to expect to donate as a normal part of end of life care. Families need to have the trust that their relative will be cared for and honoured and that their grief will be acknowledged. They need to have hope that their decision respects their loved one's wishes, and is validated with care for their loved one throughout the donation process. They require validation for their decision and acknowledgement of their gift.

We cannot blame families for declining to donate their loved one's organs when their first need to is protect and care for them and their bodies. The only place families can obtain information about organ donation processes in Australia is from the media and information in the public domain, and this is what they use to inform many of their decisions. This leaves the hospital staff with the difficult task of not only providing excellent care and communication in every facet of the patient journey, but it also requires skilled expertise to fully educate a grieving family about the organ donation process. For most people this is new and complex information, and is difficult to assimilate through the veil of emotion, shock and sleep deprivation.

There are no authoritative standardised public education resources available in Australia about what it is like to go through the experience of donating your relative's organs, and what families should expect when faced with the decision. Until there is, it is beholden for us all to consider the impact of our words and their power. An interesting comment from a participant in a study I am conducting (who declined donation) was "- so much for the recipient but nothing for the donor".

Please consider a more thoughtful approach to the way we represent organ and tissue donation in public and professional  communication. It has ramifications. For example, there were only four heart/ lung donors in Australia in 2012. The number of patients who die on the waiting list or are removed from the waiting list when dying are not published. Anecdotally the numbers are significant. I am sure it must be heart breaking to be waiting for a transplant and to be aware of the possible impact of this insensitivity. Importantly, please consider how your family would feel if asked to donate a loved one's organs because in truth if can happen to any of us at any time.